|
Texas Department of Public Safety-
State Police
Policies
Investigative Hypnosis
25.05.00 General
The use of hypnosis as an investigative tool for law
enforcement is a fairly recent development. Although it was
used for this purpose at various times, there was no
concentrated effort to develop it as a practicable working tool
until about 1970 when the use of hypnosis in several major
cases by the Los Angeles Police Department caused a number of
other police agencies to examine the possibility of such use.
Currently many major police agencies are using hypnosis to some
degree in criminal cases.
05.01
The Department recognizes that many myths and misconceptions
have developed about hypnosis and that a number of people
regard hypnosis with skepticism; however, it also recognizes
the need to utilize new investigative tools when available.
Some facts to counteract misconceptions are:
1. Hypnosis is not sleep (whatever sleep is). The subject
is
very aware of what is going on around and within their physical
environment.
2. Hypnosis is not an unconscious state. It is a
heightened
state of consciousness and may be related to subconscious
processes.
3. Hypnosis is not a mind-controlled state. The subject
will
not do anything against his/her will while in a state of
hypnosis or after.
4. Hypnosis, although often intense, is not strenuous and
the subject will not experience any adverse physiological
or psychological aftereffects. Hypnosis is a very
relaxing and comfortable experience.
5. The subject will not be asked any personal or
embarrassing questions with the exception of those questions
related directly to the investigation. The subject will not be
asked to behave in an inappropriate or unusual manner.
6. There is no danger of a hypnotized person being unable
to
return to their waking state. The subject will not stay in a
state of hypnosis following the hypnotic session. Even if the
hypnotist were to leave the room, the subject would come back
to a normal state in a short period of time, or would enter a
refreshing natural sleep.
7. Investigative hypnosis is not a substitute for proper
investigation. It is only one of the many diagnostic tools
available to officers to assist in the investigation of
criminal cases.
05.02
These guidelines are designed to outline the criteria to be
used in the selection and training of DPS personnel to use
hypnosis and the use of hypnosis by Department personnel.
25.10.00 COMMITTEE
A hypnosis oversight and training committee is established to
monitor the Department hypnosis program, review laws and court
decisions relating to the use of hypnosis, recommend
appropriate policies, develop necessary training programs, make
appropriate recommendations regarding individual hypnotists,
and perform other functions relating to hypnosis as desired by
the Director.
The committee membership shall be appointed each two (2) years
and will consist of a representative of Inspection and
Planning, a representative of Legal Services, a representative
of the Training Bureau, and at least three (3) active field
investigative hypnotists.
25.15.00 TRAINING
15.01
Selection of the proper personnel to be trained in the use of
hypnosis is fundamental to the success of the entire program.
Requests for training in investigative hypnosis may be
considered from personnel in investigative, legal, or training
categories. Each such request should be evaluated by in-line
supervisors as to the applicant's investigative background and
expertise, attitude, performance, interest in and motivation
for training, good interpersonal skills, and a liking for and
consideration of other people. Personal competence should be
the primary consideration with geographical locations also
considered. Final approval of personnel to be trained will be
made by the Director's Office with input from the Hypnosis
Oversight and Training Committee.
15.02
Personnel selected for training in investigative hypnosis will
attend a basic course of training approved by the Department
and by the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement Officer
Standards and Education. Periodic in-service and advanced
training will be scheduled. Department hypnotists will be
encouraged to join state and/or national forensic hypnosis
associations and to attend their training seminars. Future
departmental training and use will comply with any state or
national standards established.
25.20.00 AUTHORIZATION
20.01
Upon successful completion of an approved basic course of
training and/or certification as an investigative hypnotist by
the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement Officer Standards and
Education, the Director may authorize the employee as an
investigative hypnotist.
20.02
Department investigative hypnotists must be fully prepared to
testify as expert witnesses if necessary. For this reason, they
will be prepared to provide credentials whenever required. To
maintain credentials and to enhance credibility, each
investigative hypnotist shall:
1. Conduct a minimum of six (6) investigative or practice
sessions or a combination thereof each year to maintain
proficiency.
2. Attend either an in-service or approved advanced
hypnosis
course at least once each two (2) years.
20.03
The immediate supervisor of each Department investigative
hypnotist shall annually review, evaluate, and recommend
whether continued authorization should be maintained or denied.
The evaluation should consider whether the investigative
hypnotist has maintained an interest in hypnosis, sessions
reported, continued training, and research.
In-line supervisors through the service commander will add
their comments and recommendations to those of the immediate
supervisor. The service commander will forward the evaluation
and recommendations to the Hypnosis Oversight and Training
Committee for review no later than February 1. Recommendations
to the Director for denial will be forwarded by the
committee.
20.04
The Director may withdraw authorization from any Department
investigative hypnotist as a result of the evaluation and
review process or at any time continued authorization of an
investigative hypnotist would adversely affect the
Department.
25.25.00 USE
25.01
The purpose of using investigative hypnosis is to provide
additional information or clues that can be substantiated.
Evidence gathered by hypnosis will be viewed as contributory
evidence and shall be corroborated as fully as possible by
other means of investigation.
25.02
No employee of this Department shall use any hypnotic interview
technique unless authorized by the Director as an investigative
hypnotist. (See Annex #5)
25.03
Hypnosis may be used by members of this Department in felony or
misdemeanor cases when requested by a Department investigator
or other law enforcement agency. Department investigative
hypnotists should exercise discretion to assure that their
services are not being requested as a substitute for proper
investigation or for cases in which hypnosis would be of
minimal value.
25.04
No person shall be placed under hypnosis in any case in which
that person might be a defendant or suspect, nor shall any
person be placed under hypnosis when the investigative
hypnotist has reason to believe that the examination is
intended to circumvent or defy the law.
25.05
DPS investigative hypnotists will not use hypnosis for
therapeutic or public entertainment purposes. Although there is
a considerable difference of opinion as to what constitutes
therapeutic use of hypnosis, DPS policy includes weight
reduction, stopping smoking, and similar applications of
hypnosis as prohibited
activities.
Added: (Comply with all
TCLEOSE and statutory requirements.)
25.06
Prior to conducting any investigative session, the
investigative hypnotist shall obtain approval from his/her
immediate supervisor. The supervisor will be advised if the
subject is under the care or treatment of a physician,
psychiatrist, or psychologist and the reason for such care or
treatment prior to the hypnosis induction. In such cases, the
supervisor should carefully evaluate the request before
granting approval for the session.
1. If a proposed subject is under treatment for a heart
con-
dition, epilepsy, diabetes, or other serious physical
condition or is taking stimulants or sedatives, consent of the
attending physician must be obtained prior to
hypnosis induction.
2. If a proposed subject is under the care or treatment of
a
psychiatrist or psychologist, consent of the attending
psychiatrist or psychologist must be obtained prior to hypnosis
induction.
25.07
Every hypnotic session conducted by a DPS investigative
hypnotist will be recorded on audio or video tapes.
25.08
All recordings of any hypnotic session shall be retained by the
Department the same as any other evidence in a criminal case
for so long as the case for which it pertains has not resulted
in an acquittal, a final conviction, or dismissal. In any case
in which no charges are ever brought, the evidence shall be
retained until the statute of limitation for the particular
offense has run.
25.09
When the investigative hypnotist is a polygraph operator, these
additional restrictions will be imposed to separate the
function of polygraph operator from that of the investigative
hypnotist.
1. A polygraph examiner will never administer a polygraph
examination to any individual that he has hypnotized.
2. A polygraph examiner will never administer a polygraph
examination and conduct a hypnosis session on the same case or
issue.
3. While using hypnosis, the polygraph examiner should
refrain from implying or stating that he is a polygraph
examiner unless specifically asked by the subject.
4. While conducting a polygraph examination, the polygraph
examiner should refrain from implying or stating that
He is a hypnotist unless specifically asked by the subject.
5. If the polygraph examination room is to be utilized in
a hypnosis session, the polygraph instrument and its
attachments shall be removed.
25.30.0 CONDUCTING THE INTERVIEW
30.01 Preliminary Activity
1. The investigative hypnotist should never hypnotize
subjects connected with a case in which he/she is the
principal investigator as the investigative hypnotist must
remain unbiased.
2. Get background information and check on any physical or
emotional problems of the subject. Also determine any hearing
or speech problems.
3. Arrange for a time and location for the hypnosis
session.
This may be at a police facility, subject's home, or other
place where environment is as relaxing as possible.
4. Arrange for consultant, interpreter, or another
investigative hypnotist to be present, if desirable, as backup
or for communication. Investigative hypnosis will be conducted
with a witness present.
5. Arrange to have only necessary personnel at the session.
For eyewitness identifications, the hypnotist should try
to have an artist on hand who is experienced in police
identification work. If assisting another agency, have someone
from the agency present.
6. Make a brief outline of the areas of information sought:
vehicle, conversations, descriptions of suspects, weapons,
etc.
7. If subject is a juvenile, obtain written parental
consent.
30.02 Hypnosis Session
1. Have tape recording equipment on from
first contact with
the subject so that the entire contact between the hypnotist
and the subject will be recorded. The equipment should be in
plain sight and the need for it explained to subject. Record
date and location of the hypnosis session on tape. Video tape
should be used if available.
2. Introduce those present and explain the role of each
person - artist, investigator, etc.
3. Exclude family members or friends unless the subject
insists they stay.
4. Check on physical comfort: lights, temperature, etc.
Complete checklist, form HQ-124 (Annex #1), to determine any
reason why session should not be continued.
5. The investigative hypnotist will explain hypnosis to the
subject and answer any questions. After the explanation and
before inducing hypnosis, the investigative hypnotist will
obtain written consent, form HQ-125 (Annex #2), from the
witness/victim authorizing the session and will also obtain
verbal authorization on tape. For juveniles, the written
consent of the parent is also required.
6. The investigative hypnotist should use his/her own
judgment as to a practice session, type of induction
techniques, and conduct of the interview.
7. Upon the conclusion of the interview, remove all
temporary suggestions. Leave only those suggestions intended to
remain in effect post-hypnotically. Bring the subject out of
the hypnotic state feeling relaxed and refreshed.
8. Answer subject's questions and make arrangements for
repeat session if needed.
30.03 Follow-up
1. Review the tapes with the investigator. Try to determine
if subject was confabulating; review information obtained with
previous evidence gathered. Make sure that investigator is
aware of all new evidence uncovered so that it may be
corroborated. Maintain proper chain of evidence as in any
criminal case.
2. Complete and forward required
reports.
FORMS TO BE USED WHEN CONDUCTING A FORENSIC HYPNOSIS
INTERVIEW
CAN BE VIEWED BY GOING TO PROFILE OF A HYPNOSIS INTERVIEW ON
THIS WEBPAGE.
FORM HQ-123
FORM HQ-124
FORM HQ-125
|